Benefits
Liver ultrasound appearance in a 1-year trial
In a 1-year placebo-controlled trial in 87 adults with mildly raised cholesterol and fatty liver, 400 mg a day of mixed palm tocotrienols normalised the liver's ultrasound appearance in 34.9 versus 18.2 percent on placebo. Liver enzymes did not differ from placebo (ALT p = 0.118, AST p = 0.207), and almost a third of the tocotrienol group dropped out. Fatty liver needs a doctor's care.
Cholesterol: no reduction in pooled trials
A pooled analysis of 15 randomized trials found tocotrienols did not lower total cholesterol, LDL or triglycerides overall. HDL rose 0.146 mmol/L on average, though trials disagreed strongly, and in arms using 200 mg a day or more triglycerides were 0.177 mmol/L lower. In the 400 mg a day fatty liver trial, blood lipids did not differ from placebo after a year.
Oxidative-damage markers in blood
In a 6-month randomized study in 62 healthy adults, 160 mg a day of a generic palm tocotrienol fraction (not EVNol) lowered protein carbonyls, a blood marker of protein oxidation, and in those over 50, advanced glycation end-products. Over 2 years, brain white-matter lesions grew less on MRI with self-emulsifying tocotrienols than with placebo. These are markers and scans, not health outcomes.
Mechanism of action
Tocotrienol antioxidant action
In laboratory systems the unsaturated tail of a tocotrienol lets it move more freely within cell membranes than a tocopherol, and it quenches free radicals there. Whether that translates into a health outcome in people, as opposed to a change in a blood marker or a scan, has not been shown.
Cholesterol pathway in the laboratory, blunted by tocopherol
In cell and animal work, gamma and delta tocotrienol speed the breakdown of HMG-CoA reductase, the enzyme that makes cholesterol. Alpha-tocopherol blunts this. In chickens, adding alpha-tocopherol to a tocotrienol blend attenuated the effect on HMG-CoA reductase activity (p < 0.001), and blends containing 30 percent or more alpha-tocopherol worked less well than blends with 15 to 20 percent. EVNol is sold as a tocotrienol plus tocopherol complex, and the trial capsule on this page carried 61.1 mg of alpha-tocopherol against 200 mg of tocotrienols. In humans this mechanism has not produced lower LDL or total cholesterol in pooled trials.
Clinical trials
Randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled, 1 year, 87 adults at a single Malaysian centre. This liver report comes from a larger registered study, NCT00753532, which enrolled 241 people and whose registered primary outcome was brain white-matter lesion volume, with liver echogenicity listed as a secondary outcome. The study material was Tocovid Suprabio, a self-emulsifying softgel purchased from Hovid (Ipoh, Malaysia), given as 200 mg mixed tocotrienols twice daily. Two of the nine authors work for Hovid Research Sdn Bhd, four of them own shares in Hovid, and the corresponding author holds the patent on the self-emulsifying delivery system used. The research grant came from the Malaysian Palm Oil Board. (Magosso et al. 2013, Nutrition Journal)
87 untreated Malaysian adults with mildly raised cholesterol (total cholesterol 5.2 to 6.2 mmol/L) and ultrasound-proven fatty liver, mean age 51. Around three quarters had mild steatosis, the mildest of the three ultrasound grades, and mean ALT and AST were between 35 and 39 IU/L, close to the top of the normal range.
The liver's ultrasound echogenic response normalised in 34.9 percent on tocotrienols versus 18.2 percent on placebo in the intention to treat analysis (p = 0.039; odds ratio 2.411, 95 percent confidence interval 0.896 to 6.488, which crosses 1; number needed to treat 6). The authors write that tocotrienols did not significantly affect lipid profile and liver function compared with placebo. Mean 1-year falls on tocotrienols versus placebo were ALT 5.9 versus 0.6 IU/L (p = 0.118), AST 4.8 versus 3.4 (p = 0.207), total cholesterol 0.3 versus 0.2 mmol/L (p = 0.055) and triglycerides 0.2 versus 0.2 mmol/L (p = 0.814). 13 of 43 on tocotrienols and 10 of 44 on placebo dropped out and were counted as unchanged. Two people on placebo and none on tocotrienols worsened by a grade. No adverse events were reported in either group.