Benefits
Breathing symptoms and control scores in one placebo-controlled trial
The leaves carry liver-toxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids, limited to 1.0 microgram a day for adults in EU herbal medicines and 750 micrograms per kg in fresh leaves under EU food law. In a one-month double-blind trial in 38 adults with moderate asthma, a flower and leaf syrup raised control scores and cut cough and breathlessness more than placebo; lung function, exhaled nitric oxide and attacks did not differ. It is a single trial.
Smooth muscle relaxation in isolated animal tissue
Laboratory work only. A crude borage leaf extract relaxed contractions of isolated rabbit gut and windpipe tissue and relaxed precontracted rabbit aorta, in a pattern resembling calcium channel blockers, and it weakened the force and rate of isolated guinea pig heart tissue. These tissue-bath results have not been tested in people.
Blood glucose response in a rat study
Animal work only. In rats made diabetic with alloxan, a single 500 mg/kg dose of a methanol extract of borage leaves given by stomach tube lowered blood glucose 4 hours later; the 250 mg/kg dose did not show a relevant effect. Concentrated extract doses in rats do not show an effect from borage tea in people.
Genetic damage tests in fruit flies and cultured human cells
Laboratory work only. Freeze-dried borage leaves and stalks did not damage DNA in a fruit fly test and reduced DNA damage from hydrogen peroxide, and they slowed growth of a human leukemia cell line in a dish. The highest concentrations also lowered fly survival. Alkaloid levels were not measured, so these results do not show the leaves are safe to eat often.
Mechanism of action
Phenolic compounds in the leaf
Borage leaf extracts test positive for flavonoids, coumarins, sterols and tannins, and rosmarinic acid is one of the main phenolics in the leaves. In fruit fly and cell studies these phenolics showed DNA-protective and cell-killing effects similar to the whole leaf. Whether tea or salad amounts do this in people is unknown.
Calcium channel-like muscle relaxation in lab tissue
In isolated rabbit gut tissue, borage leaf extract shifted calcium response curves the way the calcium channel blocker verapamil does, which the authors proposed explains its relaxation of gut, windpipe and blood vessel tissue. This is a tissue-bath finding, not a measured effect in people.
How pyrrolizidine alkaloids injure the liver
Unsaturated pyrrolizidine alkaloids are harmless until liver CYP enzymes convert them into reactive pyrroles. These bind proteins and DNA and damage the cells lining the small liver blood vessels, which can block blood flow (hepatic sinusoidal obstruction syndrome, also called veno-occlusive disease). Some metabolites reach the lungs, and the damage can build up slowly.
Clinical trials
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled phase 2 trial of a hydroalcoholic extract of borage flowers and leaves made into a syrup by a local herbal company, 5 mL three times daily for one month, with salbutamol allowed as a reliever; registered as IRCT201209302695N4. Computer-generated randomization; patients, clinicians and outcome assessors were blinded. Funded by Islamic Azad University, Mashhad branch; the syrup maker supplied the syrup and an identical placebo. (Mirsadraee et al. 2016, Tanaffos)
42 people older than 15 with moderate persistent asthma (FEV1 60 to 79% of predicted) at a pulmonary clinic in Mashhad, Iran; 38 completed (15 women, 23 men, mean age 46.8).
After one month the asthma control test score was significantly higher with borage than placebo (15.4 vs 11.2; this compared end-of-trial values, and the borage group started lower, 10.8 vs 13.1), and fewer people on borage still had cough (16% vs 84%), shortness of breath (42% vs 94%), sputum, airway hyperresponsiveness or reflux symptoms. Exhaled nitric oxide, the co-primary outcome, spirometry, sputum eosinophils and neutrophils, and attack and emergency visit rates did not differ between groups; the drops in attacks and emergency visits were within the borage group only. Two people on borage had a skin rash and one stopped after a severe attack. The syrup was checked for alkaloids by a pharmacist, but no pyrrolizidine alkaloid levels were reported, and the discussion section misstates the sample size as 52.
Laboratory study of a crude extract of borage leaves tested on isolated rabbit jejunum, trachea and aorta and guinea pig atria, with verapamil as a reference drug. (Gilani et al. 2007, J Ethnopharmacol)
Isolated rabbit and guinea pig tissues; no human participants.
The extract relaxed spontaneous and potassium-induced gut contractions and shifted calcium concentration-response curves to the right, like verapamil. It relaxed carbachol and potassium contractions of tracheal tissue, relaxed phenylephrine and potassium contractions of aorta, and reduced the force and rate of atrial contractions. Tissue-bath results only; not tested in people.
Randomized rat study comparing methanol extracts of the leaves of four plants, including Borago officinalis, at 250 and 500 mg/kg given once by stomach tube, against saline. (Rodríguez-Magaña et al. 2019, J Diabetes Res)
72 male Wistar rats made diabetic with alloxan, 9 per group; no human participants.
Four hours after dosing, the 500 mg/kg borage extract showed relevant glucose lowering (p = 0.0112); the 250 mg/kg dose did not. The test compared glucose before and after dosing within each group, not against the control group. The extract showed no toxicity in a brine shrimp test. A single-dose, 4-hour animal result; not tested in people.
Fruit fly somatic mutation and recombination test (SMART) and HL-60 human leukemia cell assays of freeze-dried leaves and stalks from blue-flowered and white-flowered borage, plus rosmarinic, syringic and sinapic acids. (Lozano-Baena et al. 2016, Nutrients)
Drosophila melanogaster larvae and cultured HL-60 cells; no human participants.
Borage material was not genotoxic in the fly test and reduced DNA damage caused by hydrogen peroxide. It reduced HL-60 cell viability with IC50 values of 0.49 and 0.28 mg/mL for the two varieties. Alone, the highest concentration lowered fly survival to 82% (blue-flowered) and 71% (white-flowered) of controls; combined with hydrogen peroxide, the highest white-flowered concentration cut survival to about 17%. Pyrrolizidine alkaloid content was not measured. Lab results only; not tested in people.