Benefits
Hot flash frequency in women who do not make equol
In a 12-week multicenter trial in 160 postmenopausal Japanese women who did not make equol, 10 mg a day of S-equol cut daily hot flashes by 58.7%, versus 34.5% on placebo; severity and neck or shoulder stiffness also improved more. 126 women finished. The North American Menopause Society does not recommend equol for hot flashes.
Mood scores in midlife women
In a 12-week placebo-controlled trial in 134 Japanese women aged 40 to 59, 10 mg of S-equol three times a day lowered depression scores and tension, depression and fatigue ratings on a mood questionnaire, and raised vigor, compared with placebo. Other symptom gains were changes from baseline within one subgroup, not comparisons with placebo.
Hot flashes compared with soy isoflavones
In an 8-week trial of 102 postmenopausal women with at least 5 hot flashes a day, 10, 20 or 40 mg of S-equol and a soy isoflavone supplement gave similar drops in hot flash frequency at week 8; over the whole 8 weeks, 40 mg did better than isoflavones. There was no placebo group, and the lead author worked for Pharmavite, which sells an S-equol supplement.
Bone resorption marker after menopause
In a 1-year placebo-controlled pilot in 93 postmenopausal Japanese women who did not make equol, 10 mg a day of S-equol lowered urinary deoxypyridinoline, a bone breakdown marker, by 23.9% versus 2.9% on placebo, and the authors report it prevented a fall in whole-body bone density. Fractures were not studied.
Crow's-feet wrinkle area after menopause
In a 12-week placebo-controlled pilot in 101 postmenopausal Japanese women who did not make equol, 10 and 30 mg a day of S-equol reduced crow's-feet wrinkle area more than placebo, and 30 mg reduced wrinkle depth. Skin hydration, water loss and elasticity did not differ. The lead author worked at Otsuka Pharmaceutical, which makes the S-equol ingredient.
Arterial stiffness and blood sugar markers in overweight adults
In a 12-week crossover trial with no washout in 54 overweight Japanese adults, 10 mg a day of S-equol lowered HbA1c, LDL cholesterol and an arterial stiffness index versus placebo, most clearly in women who did not make equol. In 14 men who did not make equol, a single 40 mg dose did not change arterial stiffness, blood pressure or blood vessel function.
Mechanism of action
Selective binding to estrogen receptor beta
S-equol binds preferentially to estrogen receptor beta, and it has been reported to block the action of the male hormone dihydrotestosterone in vivo. These properties come from experimental research; they explain why it was tested around menopause but do not show a benefit on their own.
Supplies equol without relying on gut bacteria
Only some people carry gut bacteria that turn daidzein from soy into S-equol: 25% to 34% of the women in two of the studies cited here, and about 30% in Western populations by one estimate. The SE5-OH ingredient used in most of these trials is made by fermenting soy germ isoflavones with the equol-making bacterium Lactococcus garvieae, so it delivers S-equol directly.
Well absorbed with a half-life of about 8 hours
In 12 healthy postmenopausal women, single 10 and 30 mg doses were rapidly absorbed, with a plasma half-life of about 8 hours, and about 82% of each dose was recovered in urine. Absorption did not differ by whether women made equol themselves, though only 3 of the 12 did.
Clinical trials
Multicenter, double-blind, placebo-controlled randomized trial of a natural S-equol supplement for 12 weeks, with follow-up at week 18. (Aso et al. 2012, J Womens Health (Larchmt))
160 postmenopausal Japanese women who did not produce equol and had at least 1 hot flash a day (77 S-equol 10 mg/day, 83 placebo); 126 completed.
Daily hot flash frequency fell by 1.9 a day (58.7%) with S-equol versus 1.0 a day (34.5%) with placebo (p = 0.009). Hot flash severity and neck or shoulder muscle stiffness also fell more with S-equol. No changes in clinical lab values or serious adverse effects were reported. About one in five women did not finish.
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled 12-week trial of a new S-equol supplement at 10 mg once daily or 10 mg three times daily, with habitual isoflavone intake limited to 20 mg a day. (Ishiwata et al. 2009, Menopause)
134 Japanese women aged 40 to 59 (44 placebo, 44 at 10 mg/day, 46 at 30 mg/day); 127 completed; 34.3% were equol producers.
Compared with placebo, the 30 mg/day group had lower depression scores and lower tension-anxiety, depression-dejection and fatigue scores, with higher vigor, on the Profile of Mood States. Perimenopausal and postmenopausal non-producers on 30 mg/day improved from baseline on all menopause symptom scores except depression, a within-group change. The abstract does not report a placebo comparison for the 10 mg/day arm. One woman on 30 mg/day developed a systemic rash.
8-week randomized, double-blind, active-comparator pilot of the natural S-equol supplement SE5-OH at three doses versus soy isoflavones; lead author employed by Pharmavite LLC. (Jenks et al. 2012, J Womens Health (Larchmt))
102 postmenopausal women aged 45 to 65 with at least 5 hot flashes a day (S-equol 10, 20 or 40 mg/day, or soy isoflavones).
Hot flash frequency at week 8 fell by similar amounts in all four groups. Across the whole 8 weeks, 40 mg/day S-equol reduced frequency more than isoflavones (p = 0.021); in a subgroup with more than 8 hot flashes a day, 20 and 40 mg/day did better than isoflavones. 10 and 20 mg/day improved muscle and joint pain scores versus isoflavones. With no placebo arm, the trial cannot show how much any group beat no treatment.
1-year double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled pilot trial of natural S-equol supplements at 2, 6 or 10 mg a day. (Tousen et al. 2011, Menopause)
93 postmenopausal Japanese women who did not produce equol, split into placebo, 2, 6 and 10 mg/day groups.
At 12 months, urinary deoxypyridinoline fell 23.94% with 10 mg/day versus 2.87% with placebo (P = 0.020), and the authors report that 10 mg/day prevented a decrease in whole-body bone mineral density. Equol in blood and urine rose with dose. Sex and thyroid hormone levels did not differ among groups. A small pilot of bone markers and density; fractures were not measured.
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled 12-week pilot of a natural S-equol supplement on skin aging; lead author from Otsuka Pharmaceutical's nutraceuticals research institute. (Oyama et al. 2012, Menopause)
101 postmenopausal Japanese women who did not produce equol (34 placebo, 34 at 10 mg/day, 33 at 30 mg/day).
Both S-equol groups had a significantly larger reduction in crow's-feet wrinkle area than placebo (P < 0.05), and wrinkle depth differed from placebo at 30 mg/day only. Hydration, transepidermal water loss and elasticity did not differ in any group. Hormone tests, vaginal cytology, endometrial thickness and mammography showed no abnormal results.
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover trial with no washout period of natural S-equol tablets, 10 mg a day for 12 weeks. (Usui et al. 2013, Clin Endocrinol (Oxf))
54 overweight or obese Japanese outpatients (BMI 25 or higher); 67.9% were equol non-producers.
Compared with placebo, S-equol lowered HbA1c, LDL cholesterol and the cardio-ankle vascular index (CAVI), a measure of arterial stiffness, with larger effects in women who did not produce equol. A small crossover without a washout period; outcomes were lab markers, not health events.
Double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover study of soy isoflavones by equol-producer status, plus a separate single 40 mg dose of commercially produced S-equol (SE5-OH, donated by Otsuka Pharmaceutical) in non-producers; funded by the UK Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council. (Hazim et al. 2016, Am J Clin Nutr)
28 men at moderate cardiovascular risk (14 equol producers, 14 non-producers); the S-equol test was in the 14 non-producers.
A single 40 mg dose of S-equol did not improve carotid-femoral pulse wave velocity, blood pressure, endothelial function or nitric oxide 2 hours later in non-producers, even though plasma equol reached 3.2 micromol/L. Soy isoflavones improved pulse wave velocity at 24 hours only in men who made equol themselves. This tested one dose, not daily use.
Single-center randomized trial (alternate assignment, no placebo) of an equol supplement (10 mg S-equol, FlavoCel EQ-5, Daicel Corporation, taken with lactobionic acid) versus no supplement; funded by Advanced Medical Care Co. Ltd. (Yoshikata et al. 2021, PLoS One)
57 postmenopausal Japanese women (mean age 56); 27 received the supplement.
More women improved on a climacteric symptom questionnaire with the supplement than without it (81% vs 53%, p = 0.045). There was no benefit on the main metabolic and aging biomarkers overall; skin advanced glycation end products and visceral fat improved only in some subgroups, mainly equol producers. With no placebo, the symptom result may include an expectation effect.