Benefits
Urinary symptom scores in older men
In a 6-month placebo-controlled trial in 128 men in their mid 60s with a benign enlarged prostate, a 500 mg daily extract lowered the International Prostate Symptom Score from 13.4 to 11.5 points, while placebo went from 13.0 to 13.6. The gap of about 2.5 points is small, and it comes from a single trial sponsored by the extract's maker.
Nighttime urination in men
In the same trial, trips to urinate on the night before each visit fell from an average of 1.2 to 0.8 with the extract and rose from 1.1 to 1.3 with placebo, a difference the authors' statistical model found significant. The men started with mild nighttime urination, and the count came from a single night before each visit.
Urine left in the bladder after voiding
Residual urine after voiding, measured by ultrasound, was a main outcome. The authors reported a significant shift toward lower volumes with the extract, but the group average barely moved (40.4 to 39.5 ml, against 28.0 to 31.4 ml on placebo), and the extract group started higher. Prostate size, the other main outcome, did not differ from placebo.
Traditional EU herbal tea for men's urinary comfort
The European Medicines Agency recognizes willow herb tea as a traditional herbal medicine for relief of lower urinary tract symptoms linked to a benign enlarged prostate, to be used only after a doctor has excluded serious conditions. This rests on use in Austria, Germany and Poland since at least the early 1980s; its review found no clinical efficacy studies.
Multi-herb formulas that include willow herb
In a 3-month placebo-controlled trial in 57 men with a benign enlarged prostate, a daily capsule of small-flowered willow herb with saw palmetto, pygeum, pumpkin seed and lycopene cut median symptom scores by 36% against 8% and lowered day and night urination. Small uncontrolled studies of other blends reported gains. None can show what willow herb adds.
Oenothein B and prostate cell activity in lab studies
In enzyme tests, oenothein B from willow herb blocked 5-alpha-reductase, which converts testosterone to DHT, and partly blocked aromatase. Willow herb extracts and urolithins, which gut bacteria make from its tannins, slowed prostate cell growth and PSA release in cell culture, and an extract eased testosterone-induced prostate enlargement in rats. These are lab and animal findings.
Mechanism of action
Oenothein B inhibits enzymes that make DHT (enzyme assays)
Activity-guided studies of small-flowered and other willow herbs identified the ellagitannins oenothein B and oenothein A as the compounds that inhibit 5-alpha-reductase and aromatase in test-tube assays. The European Medicines Agency found no human data showing these effects after oral use.
Gut bacteria turn its tannins into urolithins
The extract's polyphenols degraded in a lab model of stomach and small intestine digestion, and in mice urolithins, the gut-bacteria products of these tannins, appeared only after repeated dosing. Human gut bacteria converted tannins from a related willow herb species into urolithins, which slowed prostate cell growth in culture. Lab and animal findings.
Anti-inflammatory and enzyme effects in prostate cells and rats
A willow herb water extract and oenothein B raised activity of neutral endopeptidase, a peptide-degrading enzyme, in prostate cancer cells. In testosterone-treated rats, an oral extract lowered androgen levels, NF-kB expression, inflammation and oxidative stress in the prostate. These are cell and animal results.
Clinical trials
Single-center, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in Benevento, Italy, of one gastro-resistant capsule a day of E. angustifolium extract (ENOTprost, at least 15% oenothein B) for 6 months; registered as ISRCTN18705154 with the extract maker EPO Srl as sponsor and funder. (Esposito et al. 2021, Biomed Pharmacother)
128 men with a benign enlarged prostate diagnosed by ultrasound, blood tests and symptom score, not taking prostate drugs (70 extract, 58 placebo; mean age 67 and 64). Baseline symptom scores were moderate (about 13 points) and nighttime urination mild (about 1 trip).
Prostate volume, a main outcome, did not change differently between groups. For residual urine, the other main outcome, the authors' model showed a significant shift toward lower volumes, although means barely changed (40.4 to 39.5 ml vs 28.0 to 31.4 ml). Symptom scores went from 13.4 to 11.5 vs 13.0 to 13.6 on placebo, and nighttime trips from 1.2 to 0.8 vs 1.1 to 1.3. PSA showed no treatment effect, and the blood neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio, an inflammation marker and a secondary outcome, did not change over time. No extract-related adverse effects were reported and liver and kidney tests showed no treatment effect. Two authors were employees of the maker, and the registry entry listed at least 5 months of treatment and different, narrower entry criteria than the paper reports.
Phase II randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of one capsule a day of a blend of pumpkin seed (Cucurbita pepo), Epilobium parviflorum, lycopene, pygeum and saw palmetto for 3 months. (Coulson et al. 2013, Complement Ther Med)
57 otherwise healthy men aged 40 to 80 with medically diagnosed benign prostatic hyperplasia (32 blend, 25 placebo).
Median symptom score (IPSS) fell 36% on the blend against 8% on placebo (p < 0.05). Daytime urination fell from 7.0 to 5.9 times a day (placebo 6.2 to 6.3) and nighttime urination from 2.9 to 1.8 (placebo 2.8 to 2.6). The blend was reported as well tolerated. With five ingredients, the effect of willow herb alone cannot be separated, and the abstract does not name the funder.