Benicaros™ (Carrot Rhamnogalacturonan-I Prebiotic)

Evidence Level
Limited
3 Clinical Trials
4 Documented Benefits
2/5 Evidence Score

Benicaros™ (NutriLeads) is a carrot pomace-derived rhamnogalacturonan-I (cRG-I) prebiotic, a specific pectic polysaccharide isolated from carrot processing leftovers. Unlike traditional fiber-style prebiotics that operate primarily through bulk fermentation and short-chain fatty acid production, cRG-I is proposed to act through both microbiota modulation and direct immune signalling in the gut, though the signalling part is inferred from laboratory work rather than measured in people. The human evidence is a single randomized trial: 177 healthy adults aged 18 to 65 took 0, 0.3 or 1.5 g/day for eight weeks and were then deliberately given rhinovirus-16 in a laboratory. At 0.3 g/day, symptom severity was about 20 percent lower and symptom duration about 25 percent shorter than placebo, but the higher 1.5 g/day dose did less well, for reasons that are not established. That one trial has been published as three separate papers, all funded by NutriLeads, the manufacturer, and no independent group has repeated it.

Studied Dose 0.3 g/day and 1.5 g/day cRG-I in the one human trial; 0.3 g/day outperformed 1.5 g/day on symptoms, which is unexplained.
Active Compound Carrot-derived rhamnogalacturonan-I (cRG-I), a pectic polysaccharide from carrot pomace; Benicaros™ (NutriLeads).

Benefits

Accelerated innate antiviral immune response

Low-dose cRG-I has been associated with faster interferon-induced antiviral responses to rhinovirus infection in humans, supporting an immune-priming effect of dietary RG-I beyond classical prebiotic fermentation. This rests on one manufacturer-funded trial in 177 people who were deliberately inoculated with rhinovirus-16 in a laboratory. The dose pattern was inconsistent: innate immune activation was strongest at 1.5 g/day, while the faster interferon response and faster viral clearance came at 0.3 g/day.

Symptom severity and duration after a laboratory rhinovirus challenge

Low-dose cRG-I was associated with reduced symptom severity and shorter symptom duration versus placebo in healthy adults. Severity was about 20 percent lower and duration about 25 percent shorter at 0.3 g/day, in a single trial of 177 people. The infection was a deliberate laboratory inoculation with rhinovirus-16 in healthy 18 to 65 year olds; nothing here tested colds caught naturally over a winter. The 1.5 g/day dose did less well than 0.3 g/day.

More Bifidobacterium, overall microbiota largely unchanged

Daily supplementation with rhamnogalacturonan-I left the overall gut microbiota composition generally unaltered in the one trial that measured it, which the authors put down to the very low fiber dose. What did change: relative abundance of Bifidobacterium, mainly B. adolescentis and B. longum, rose significantly at both 0.3 and 1.5 g/day, and microbiota variability between and within people fell in a dose-dependent way. The same paper reports that respiratory symptom severity did not directly correlate with these microbial changes.

Studied at low daily doses

Unlike traditional fiber-style prebiotics that often require multi-gram doses, cRG-I appears clinically active at sub-gram intakes (~0.3 g/day). In practice that means a small capsule rather than a fiber scoop. It also means more is not better here: the 1.5 g/day arm did less well than 0.3 g/day on symptoms and viral clearance, and the reason is unknown.

Mechanism of action

1

Direct gut immune signalling via pattern recognition

RG-I pectic polysaccharides are thought to interact with pattern-recognition receptors on intestinal epithelial cells and resident immune cells, modulating cytokine and interferon signalling. The evidence for this receptor interaction comes from laboratory and animal work; it was not measured in the human trial, so treat it as a proposed explanation rather than a demonstrated one.

2

Innate antiviral priming of interferon pathways

Daily cRG-I supplementation is associated with faster type I interferon responses after deliberate rhinovirus-16 inoculation in one human trial. Priming of the innate antiviral interferon pathway is the leading hypothesis for the observed reductions in cold-type symptom severity and duration.

3

Microbiota composition modulation

The microbiota substudy found the overall community composition generally unaltered at these low doses. One change was clear: more Bifidobacterium at both 0.3 and 1.5 g/day, alongside a dose-dependent drop in how much microbiota profiles varied between and within people. Whether any of that drives the respiratory result is unknown, since symptom severity did not track the microbial changes.

Clinical trials

1
cRG-I rhinovirus-16 challenge trial (the only trial; paper 1 of 3 from it)

Randomized, placebo-controlled trial of carrot-derived rhamnogalacturonan-I (cRG-I) at 0, 0.3, or 1.5 g/day in 177 healthy individuals aged 18–65 years before and during experimental rhinovirus-16 challenge. Primary outcomes were symptom severity, symptom duration and viral load in nasal lavage; innate immune and interferon markers were secondary. Published in Nutrients, Lutter 2021. Funded by NutriLeads, which supplied the product and had a role in study design, data analysis, data interpretation and writing the report.

177 healthy adults aged 18 to 65. After eight weeks of supplementation they were deliberately inoculated with rhinovirus-16 in a laboratory; nobody caught a cold naturally.

At 0.3 g/day cRG-I, participants experienced a faster interferon-induced response and reduced symptom severity (~20%) and duration (~25%) versus placebo. The higher 1.5 g/day dose produced the strongest innate immune activation, yet its antiviral response, viral clearance and symptom scores fell between placebo and 0.3 g/day. A higher dose working less well is unexplained and is a reason for caution rather than confidence. All three trial entries on this page come from this single study.

2
Same trial, secondary analysis: immune markers and quality of life

Secondary analysis of the same rhinovirus-16 challenge trial, not a new study. Its stated aim was to elaborate on the initial findings. It adds ex vivo whole-blood TLR3 stimulation, NK cell function and quality-of-life scores in the same participants. Published in Nutrients, McKay 2022. Funded by NutriLeads.

The same volunteers as the 2021 trial. No new participants were enrolled.

cRG-I supplementation was associated with accelerated immune responses and improvements in quality-of-life measures during rhinovirus challenge. Because this analyses the same participants rather than a second study, it cannot independently confirm the first result. Count the three papers on this page as one trial.

3
Same trial, gut microbiota substudy

Gut microbiota substudy of the same rhinovirus-16 challenge trial, not a separate study. Participants took placebo (n=46), 0.3 g/day (n=49) or 1.5 g/day (n=51) for eight weeks before the challenge. Published in Biomedicine & Pharmacotherapy, Jian 2024. Funded by NutriLeads.

The same trial cohort; the microbiota substudy reports 46 people on placebo, 49 at 0.3 g/day and 51 at 1.5 g/day, 146 in all.

Daily supplementation with rhamnogalacturonan-I left the overall gut microbiota composition generally unaltered, which the authors put down to the very low fiber dose. Bifidobacterium relative abundance, mainly B. adolescentis and B. longum, increased significantly at both doses, and microbiota heterogeneity between and within people fell in a dose-dependent way. The authors also state that the severity of respiratory symptoms did not directly correlate with the cRG-I-induced microbial changes.

Side effects and drug interactions

Common Potential side effects

Generally well tolerated at studied doses (0.3–1.5 g/day).
Mild gastrointestinal effects (bloating, transient stool changes) possible.
No notable adverse events were reported in the one published trial, which used about eight weeks of supplementation before the viral challenge.
Long-term safety is unknown. The only human trial lasted about eight weeks, and there is no independent replication.
Not extensively studied in pregnancy, lactation, or pediatric populations.

Important Drug interactions

Immunosuppressants (cyclosporine, tacrolimus): entirely theoretical. No interaction has been studied or reported for cRG-I; the concern is inferred from its immune-priming effect. Raise it with your clinician.
Biologic immune-modulating drugs such as TNF-alpha inhibitors: also entirely theoretical, with no data either way. Discuss with the prescribing clinician before regular use.
Broad-spectrum antibiotics: could in theory disrupt any microbiota-mediated effect. Not studied.
No interaction studies have been run with cardiovascular or metabolic medicines, so nothing can be ruled in or out.

Frequently asked questions about Benicaros™ (Carrot Rhamnogalacturonan-I Prebiotic)

What is Benicaros?

Benicaros™ (NutriLeads) is a carrot pomace-derived rhamnogalacturonan-I (cRG-I) prebiotic, a specific pectic polysaccharide isolated from carrot processing leftovers.

What is Benicaros used for?

Benicaros is researched primarily for Immune Support and Gut Health. Low-dose cRG-I has been associated with faster interferon-induced antiviral responses to rhinovirus infection in humans, supporting an immune-priming effect of dietary RG-I beyond classical prebiotic fermentation.

What is the recommended dosage of Benicaros?

The clinically studied dose is 0.3 g/day and 1.5 g/day cRG-I in the one human trial; 0.3 g/day outperformed 1.5 g/day on symptoms, which is unexplained. Always follow the product label and check with a healthcare provider for personal advice.

Is Benicaros safe, and does it have side effects?

For most healthy adults, Benicaros is well tolerated at studied doses. Reported effects can include: Generally well tolerated at studied doses (0.3–1.5 g/day). Mild gastrointestinal effects (bloating, transient stool changes) possible. It may also interact with some medications. Benicaros is not right for everyone, so check with a healthcare provider first if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a medical condition, or take prescription medication.

Does Benicaros interact with any medications?

Possible interactions include: Immunosuppressants (cyclosporine, tacrolimus): entirely theoretical. No interaction has been studied or reported for cRG-I; the concern is inferred from its immune-priming effect. Raise it with your clinician. If you take prescription medication, check with a pharmacist or doctor before using it.

How strong is the scientific evidence for Benicaros?

NutraSmarts rates the evidence for Benicaros as Limited (2 out of 5). It is backed by 3 clinical trials and 3 cited references summarized on this page. A higher rating reflects more, larger, and better-designed human studies.

References(3 citations)

Evidence ratings on NutraSmarts are based on the totality of human clinical research, with emphasis on randomized controlled trials, meta-analyses, and systematic reviews. The references below directly support claims made throughout this page.

  1. Lutter R, Teitsma-Jansen A, Floris E, Lone-Latif S, Ravi A, Sabogal Pineros YS, Dekker T, Smids B, Khurshid R, Aparicio-Vergara M, Ruijschop R, Ravanetti L, Calame W, Kardinaal A, Albers R. The Dietary Intake of Carrot-Derived Rhamnogalacturonan-I Accelerates and Augments the Innate Immune and Anti-Viral Interferon Response to Rhinovirus Infection and Reduces Duration and Severity of Symptoms in Humans in a Randomized Trial. Nutrients. 2021;13(12):4395. doi: 10.3390/nu13124395.PubMedUsed to support: Lead RCT in 177 healthy adults: low-dose carrot RG-I (0.3 g/day) accelerated the interferon-induced response and reduced rhinovirus symptom severity (about 20%) and duration (about 25%) vs placebo; the higher 1.5 g/day dose did less well than the lower one, which is unexplained. Honesty: this is the only trial of the ingredient, the infection was a deliberate laboratory inoculation, and NutriLeads funded it and had a role in study design, data analysis, interpretation and writing.
  2. McKay S, Teitsma-Jansen A, Floris E, Dekker T, Smids B, Khurshid R, Calame W, Kardinaal A, Lutter R, Albers R. Effects of Dietary Supplementation with Carrot-Derived Rhamnogalacturonan-I (cRG-I) on Accelerated Protective Immune Responses and Quality of Life in Healthy Volunteers Challenged with Rhinovirus in a Randomized Trial. Nutrients. 2022;14(20):4258. doi: 10.3390/nu14204258.PubMedUsed to support: Secondary analysis of the 2021 trial, not a new RCT. Reports ex vivo TLR3 and NK cell responses plus quality-of-life scores in the same participants. Honesty: same cohort, so it cannot independently confirm the first paper, and NutriLeads funded it.
  3. Jian C, Sorensen N, Lutter R, Albers R, de Vos W, Salonen A, Mercenier A. The impact of daily supplementation with rhamnogalacturonan-I on the gut microbiota in healthy adults: A randomized controlled trial. Biomed Pharmacother. 2024;174:116561. doi: 10.1016/j.biopha.2024.116561.PubMedUsed to support: Gut microbiota substudy of the same 2021 challenge trial, not a separate RCT. Overall microbiota composition was generally unaltered at these low doses; Bifidobacterium relative abundance rose significantly at both doses and microbiota heterogeneity fell dose-dependently. Honesty: symptom severity did not correlate directly with the microbial changes, and NutriLeads funded the study.