Benefits
Anise-flavored herb used with tart fruit, in desserts and in tea
A spice handbook describes sweet cicely leaves cooked with rhubarb, gooseberries and other fruits, used in fruit salads, salads and drinks, and dried for herbal tea; the seeds go into cakes and candy and the root can be eaten or candied. A Slovenian study of traditional wild food use, combining cookbooks, ethnological sources and a survey, listed the leaves and fruits in syrups, beverages and desserts.
Leaf essential oil led by (E)-anethole
Lab analyses only. Hydrodistilled leaf oil from plants grown in a botanical garden held 82 to 85% (E)-anethole among 16 identified compounds, and leaf oil from plants grown in Finland held 83.1% among 39 compounds. Anethole is also the main flavor compound of anise seed and fennel.
Antifungal activity of the essential oil in lab tests
Lab work only. In a test against seven bacteria and six fungi, sweet cicely essential oil had the weakest antibacterial effect of the three oils tested but the strongest antifungal effect, and minimal inhibitory and fungicidal concentrations against the fungi ranged from 0.5 to 120 micrograms per ml in the study as a whole. This shows nothing about eating the herb.
Metal content of a wild-harvested sample within modeled intake limits
Lab analysis only. A wild sample of sweet cicely aerial parts from Ireland was profiled for a panel of elements. No risk was found at modeled intakes of 200 mg or 200 g a day; at the higher intake the hazard index for cadmium, mercury and lead was 0.62, below the level of concern of 1. One sample from one site cannot describe products in general.
Mechanism of action
Anethole-rich oil carries the anise-like taste
Sweet cicely leaf oil is dominated by (E)-anethole, a flavor compound it shares with anise seed and fennel. A spice handbook notes that sweet cicely fruits can stand in for anise or fennel and that its leaves taste like chervil but stronger. Flavor is the established role; no health effect of this has been measured.
Estragole needs liver activation to become reactive
The EMA explains that liver enzymes, mainly CYP1A2, convert estragole to 1'-hydroxyestragole, which the sulfotransferase SULT1A1 turns into a reactive form that binds DNA. Such adducts have been found in mice and rats, and the EMA classes estragole as a genotoxic liver carcinogen in rodents.
Anethole and estragole behave differently in rodent studies
The EMA statement cites a rat liver gene expression model that grouped estragole and safrole with liver carcinogens and anethole, eugenol and isoeugenol with noncarcinogens, based on earlier rodent bioassays. The balance of the two compounds in a given sweet cicely sample may therefore matter, and no measurement of it in retail sweet cicely products was found.
Clinical trials
Hydrodistilled leaf oil of sweet cicely (Myrrhis odorata) grown in Finland, analyzed by gas chromatography and gas chromatography with mass spectrometry. (Uusitalo et al. 1999, J Essent Oil Res)
No participants; chemical analysis of plant oil only.
Thirty-nine compounds were identified, and (E)-anethole (83.1%) was the major constituent. The abstract does not report an estragole value, and the study tested no biological effect.
Comparison of the essential oils of Myrrhis odorata, Hypericum perforatum and Helichrysum arenarium against seven bacteria and six fungi, using a bioautographic test on TLC plates for the bacteria and Candida albicans and a microdilution test for the other fungi. (Rancic et al. 2005, J Essent Oil Res)
No participants; bacterial and fungal cultures only.
Sweet cicely oil had the weakest antibacterial effect of the three oils, but the best antifungal activity, outperforming a commercial product; across the study, minimal inhibitory and fungicidal concentrations for the fungi were 0.5 to 120 micrograms per ml. Effects of an oil in a dish do not show what eating the herb does.
Multi-element analysis by high resolution ICP mass spectrometry of 50 botanical samples, including wild-collected aerial parts of sweet cicely from Ireland, with modeled hazard quotients and a hazard index at intakes of 200 mg and 200 g a day. (Kenny et al. 2022, Sci Rep)
No participants; one sweet cicely plant sample among 50 botanical samples.
This was the first reported metal profile of sweet cicely. No risk was detected for the sweet cicely sample at either modeled intake (hazard index 0.62 at 200 g a day), while 42% of all samples were flagged for possible cumulative exposure at high intake. The result applies to one sample, not to all sweet cicely products.