Benefits
Red blood cell and plasma folate status
In trials of Metafolin against placebo, blood folate rose at every dose tested. Against equal molar folic acid, an active comparator, 416 mcg a day raised red blood cell folate more over 24 weeks in 136 women, and 1.13 mg a day gave higher levels at 12 weeks in Malaysian women (75 completed); at 113 mcg a day, and at 625 mcg a day in pregnancy, levels did not differ.
Homocysteine, a blood marker
Metafolin lowered plasma homocysteine compared with placebo in three trials. Against folic acid, the fall was similar at 208 or 416 mcg and at 1.13 mg a day, and larger at 113 mcg a day (14.6 versus 9.3 percent below placebo). Homocysteine is a marker: in pooled trials of homocysteine-lowering B vitamins, heart attacks and deaths did not fall, with a small drop in stroke.
Folate status in pregnancy
In 60 pregnant people given 625 mcg of Metafolin or an equal molar 600 mcg of folic acid a day for 16 weeks, red blood cell and serum folate did not differ between groups, while unmetabolized folic acid in plasma was about half as high on Metafolin, a difference the authors call of unclear relevance. The trial measured blood markers, not birth outcomes.
Folate status while breastfeeding
In 69 women assigned after delivery, 416 mcg of Metafolin a day for 16 weeks kept red blood cell folate higher than placebo and higher than a 400 mcg folic acid reference group, which was not randomized. The women had taken folic acid through pregnancy and ate fortified foods. The maker co-funded the trial.
Plasma folate response by MTHFR 677 genotype
In a single-dose crossover in 24 women with the MTHFR 677 TT or CC genotype, 416 mcg of Metafolin raised plasma folate more than 400 mcg of folic acid in both groups, about twice as much in TT women by area under the curve. A Merck company supplied and funded it, and a study of another maker's 5-MTHF found equal short-term absorption in men.
Mechanism of action
Active folate without the conversion steps
Folic acid must first be reduced by the enzyme dihydrofolate reductase and then converted, with the MTHFR enzyme making the final 5-MTHF form, the main folate in plasma. Metafolin supplies L-5-MTHF directly. In a single-dose study, plasma folate was mostly 5-MTHF after either form, while unmetabolized folic acid appeared regularly after folic acid and rarely after Metafolin.
Vitamin B12 dependent recycling and the masking question
5-MTHF passes its methyl group to homocysteine through methionine synthase, a vitamin B12 dependent enzyme, which regenerates tetrahydrofolate. Trial authors propose that, because of this step, 5-MTHF is less able than folic acid to correct the anemia of B12 deficiency and so less likely to mask it. None of the trials cited here tested this in people with B12 deficiency.
Clinical trials
Double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled parallel trial; 416 or 208 mcg [6S]-5-MTHF calcium salt (Metafolin, Merck Eprova AG), 400 mcg folic acid as an equimolar active comparator, or placebo daily for 24 weeks; the earlier report from this trial states that Merck KGaA contributed financially and a Merck Eprova AG scientist was a co-author (Lamers et al. 2006, Am J Clin Nutr)
144 healthy women aged 19 to 33 in Bonn, Germany, with adequate vitamin B12; 136 analyzed.
Red blood cell folate rose more over time on 416 mcg Metafolin than on 400 mcg folic acid or 208 mcg Metafolin (P < 0.001), and more on folic acid than on 208 mcg. Plasma folate plateaued after 12 weeks; red cell folate had not plateaued by 24 weeks. Red cell folate is a marker of folate status, not a measured pregnancy outcome.
Double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled parallel trial (same 144 women as the red cell folate report); Metafolin from Merck Eprova AG named in the methods; funded in part by Merck KGaA, with a Merck Eprova AG co-author; 24 weeks (Lamers et al. 2004, Am J Clin Nutr)
144 healthy women in Bonn, Germany, recruited at ages 18 to 35 with adequate vitamin B12; 135 analyzed.
Plasma homocysteine fell on all three active supplements, and the fall did not differ between 400 mcg folic acid, 416 mcg and 208 mcg Metafolin. The plasma folate rise was smaller on 208 mcg than on folic acid or 416 mcg. No side effects were reported.
Double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled 24 week trial; 113 mcg L-MTHF calcium salt (Metafolin, supplied by Eprova AG, whose chief scientific officer was a co-author) or an equimolar 100 mcg folic acid active comparator or placebo daily (Venn et al. 2003, Am J Clin Nutr)
167 healthy adults in New Zealand who did not take folic acid supplements and were not regular consumers of folic acid fortified foods (under 3 servings a week); 155 analyzed.
Compared with placebo, homocysteine was 14.6 percent lower on Metafolin and 9.3 percent lower on folic acid (P < 0.001 versus placebo; P = 0.045 between the active arms). Plasma folate and red cell folate rose on both, and the rises did not differ significantly between them. Homocysteine is a blood marker.
Sixteen week, double-blind trial: women randomized after delivery to 416 mcg [6S]-5-methylTHF a day or placebo, plus a nonrandomized 400 mcg folic acid reference group; the paper identifies the form as Metafolin and was supported by Merck Eprova AG and a Canadian research council (Houghton et al. 2006, Am J Clin Nutr)
69 healthy breastfeeding women in Toronto who had taken folic acid in pregnancy; 64 completed.
At 16 weeks, red blood cell folate after baseline adjustment was higher on [6S]-5-methylTHF (2178 nmol/L) than in the folic acid reference group (1967 nmol/L, P < 0.05) or on placebo (1390 nmol/L). Because the folic acid group was not randomized, that comparison is weaker than the placebo comparison.
Randomized crossover pharmacokinetic study; single oral 416 mcg [6S]-5-MTHF (Metafolin from Merck Selbstmedikation GmbH, which also funded the study) or an equimolar 400 mcg folic acid; plasma folate measured for 8 hours (Prinz-Langenohl et al. 2009, Br J Pharmacol)
24 healthy women: 16 with the MTHFR 677 TT genotype and 8 with CC.
Plasma folate area under the curve and peak were higher, and time to peak shorter, after Metafolin than after folic acid in both genotypes; in TT women the area under the curve was about twice as high. Unmetabolized folic acid appeared regularly after folic acid and rarely after Metafolin. No treatment-related adverse events occurred.
Double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial; 1.13 mg L-5-MTHF calcium salt (Metafolin, Eprova) or an equimolar 1 mg folic acid active comparator or cellulose placebo daily; registered NCT01584050; high loss to follow-up (Henderson et al. 2018, J Nutr)
142 women aged 20 to 45 in Malaysia, where folic acid fortification is not mandatory; 108 attended baseline and 75 completed (20 on Metafolin).
At 12 weeks, red blood cell folate (1951 versus 1498 nmol/L, P = 0.003) and plasma folate were higher on Metafolin than on folic acid. Homocysteine was 15 percent (Metafolin) and 17 percent (folic acid) lower than placebo, with no difference between the two. Vitamin B12, methyl nutrients and LINE-1 methylation did not differ.
Double-blind randomized trial of 0.625 mg Metafolin (donated by Merck & Cie) or an equimolar 0.6 mg folic acid active comparator daily for 16 weeks with a folate-free prenatal vitamin; registered NCT04022135 (Cochrane et al. 2024, Br J Nutr)
60 pregnant people at 8 to 21 weeks' gestation in Vancouver, Canada; 54 analyzed.
Erythrocyte folate (1826 versus 1998 nmol/L) and serum folate did not differ between groups after adjustment. Plasma unmetabolized folic acid was 0.6 nmol/L higher on folic acid, roughly twice the level on Metafolin; the authors call the biological relevance unclear. Birth outcomes were not studied.