Benefits
Blood lipid markers with lupin protein
In adults with high blood cholesterol, 25 g/day of lupin protein built into foods for 28 days gave lower LDL cholesterol than milk protein, and 35 g/day for 6 weeks gave a lower LDL to HDL ratio than casein. A 25 g/day lupin protein isolate drink did not differ from milk protein in lipids over 8 weeks. These are blood markers, not heart outcomes.
Plant protein source with a lower amino acid score than whey
In a lab comparison, essential amino acids made up 21 percent of lupin protein against 43 percent of whey, and leucine, lysine and methionine were all below requirement, so about 52 g of lupin protein matched the leucine in 25 g of whey. In 9 healthy men, about 91 percent of lupin flour protein was digested, and it was used about as well as soy protein.
Blood pressure with lupin kernel flour bread
In 74 overweight adults, eating bread made with lupin kernel flour, which adds fiber as well as protein, instead of white bread for 16 weeks lowered 24-hour systolic blood pressure by 3.0 mm Hg, with no change in diastolic pressure. A 12-month trial found 1 mm Hg lower pressures only at 12 months, and 8-week trials of lupin foods or a lupin protein isolate drink found no difference from control.
Fullness and next-meal intake after a lupin bread breakfast
In 16 adults, a breakfast of lupin kernel flour bread raised fullness ratings and cut energy intake at lunch by 488 kJ versus an energy-matched white bread breakfast, and it lowered the hunger hormone ghrelin in a second group. These were single meals; over 12 months, lupin-enriched foods did not add to weight loss.
Smaller blood sugar rise when added to a carbohydrate meal
In 12 healthy young adults, adding sweet lupin flour to a carbohydrate-rich meal blunted the first-hour blood sugar rise by 54 percent versus the meal alone, as much as whey did. In 24 adults with type 2 diabetes, lupin kernel flour added to a glucose drink lowered the glucose response. Eight weeks of lupin foods did not change average blood sugar.
Mechanism of action
Amino acid supply and the leucine signal
Eating protein raises blood essential amino acids, and leucine helps switch on muscle protein synthesis. In one commercial lupin protein, essential amino acids were 21 percent of protein and leucine 5.2 percent, below WHO/FAO/UNU requirements, with lysine (3.5 percent) and methionine (0.3 percent) also low, so a larger serving or a blend is needed to match whey.
Digestibility of lupin protein
In 9 healthy men, sampled at the end of the small intestine, real ileal digestibility of 15N-labeled sweet lupin flour protein was 91 percent, and its use after the meal was similar to that of a soy protein isolate, even though the flour is rich in fiber.
Protein and fiber in place of refined carbohydrate
Lupin kernel flour is high in protein and fiber and low in carbohydrate. In the 16-week bread trial, swapping it into bread raised daily protein by 13.7 g and fiber by 12.5 g versus white bread, the dietary shift the trial was designed to test for blood pressure; the trial did not separate the effect of protein from that of fiber.
Clinical trials
Randomized parallel trial (registered ACTRN12606000034538) in which participants replaced 15 to 20 percent of their usual daily energy with lupin kernel flour-enriched bread or white bread for 16 weeks, with 24-hour ambulatory blood pressure at baseline and 16 weeks; blood pressure was the stated objective. A whole-flour food, so protein and fiber rose together. Funding is not stated in the abstract (Lee et al. 2009, Am J Clin Nutr)
88 overweight and obese men and women; 74 completed (37 per group), with normal average blood pressure at baseline.
Versus white bread, lupin bread raised protein intake by 13.7 g/day and fiber by 12.5 g/day. 24-hour systolic blood pressure was 3.0 mm Hg lower (P = 0.03) and pulse pressure 3.5 mm Hg lower (P < 0.001), while diastolic pressure (P = 0.47) and heart rate did not differ.
Randomized parallel trial of lupin-enriched foods versus matching high-carbohydrate control foods through 3 months of energy restriction, 1 month of weight stabilization and 8 months of weight maintenance; body weight, body composition and cardiovascular risk factors were measured at baseline, 4 and 12 months. Funding is not stated in the abstract (Belski et al. 2011, Int J Obes (Lond))
131 overweight men and women.
Lupin did not change weight loss at 4 months (0.1 kg) or 12 months (-0.6 kg), weight maintenance, body fat or fat-free mass versus control. 24-hour systolic and diastolic blood pressure were 1.3 and 1.0 mm Hg lower at 12 months but not at 4 months, and fasting insulin and HOMA scores were lower at both times.
Double-blind randomized crossover trial of lupin-enriched bread, pasta, breakfast cereal and crumbs versus energy-matched control foods, eaten at breakfast and lunch daily and at dinner at least 3 days a week for 8 weeks each, with an 8-week washout. Funding is not stated in the abstract (Ward et al. 2020, Food Funct)
22 adults with type 2 diabetes (14 men, 8 women; mean age 58); 17 completed both arms and all were analyzed.
Lupin foods had no significant effect on mean blood glucose (P = 0.214) or post-meal glucose (P = 0.196), home systolic (P = 0.33) or diastolic (P = 0.321) blood pressure, heart rate, or body weight versus control foods.
Randomized, controlled, double-blind crossover trial (NCT01304992) of 25 g/day Lupinus angustifolius protein isolate or milk protein isolate in drinks for 8 weeks each, separated by a 4-week washout; LDL cholesterol was the primary outcome. Funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (Bähr et al. 2013, Nutr J)
33 adults with high blood cholesterol.
Blood pressure and plasma lipids did not differ between lupin and milk protein, except higher HDL cholesterol at week 4 with lupin. LDL cholesterol fell from baseline at week 4 with both proteins, only in those with higher cholesterol, and the change was gone by week 8. Blood pressure fell from baseline within the lupin phase at week 8. Both proteins slightly raised body weight and body fat.
Randomized, controlled, double-blind three-phase crossover trial (NCT01598649) of 25 g/day lupin protein, milk protein, or milk protein plus 1.6 g/day arginine, built into bread, rolls, sausage and a vegetarian spread for 28 days each with 6-week washouts; the registered primary outcome was change in cholesterol metabolism. Funding is not stated in the abstract (Bähr et al. 2015, Clin Nutr)
72 adults with high blood cholesterol; 68 included in the final analysis.
LDL cholesterol was significantly lower after lupin protein than after milk protein, and homocysteine was lower than after both milk protein diets. Total and LDL cholesterol fell more in those with higher baseline cholesterol. These are blood markers measured over 4 weeks, not heart outcomes.
Two randomized controlled crossover single-meal trials comparing lupin kernel flour-enriched bread with white bread at an energy-matched breakfast (1655 kJ) and at lunch, with ad libitum lunch intake measured in study 1 and blood sampling for 3 hours in study 2. Funding is not stated in the abstract (Lee et al. 2006, Am J Clin Nutr)
16 adults (study 1) and 17 adults (study 2).
The lupin bread breakfast gave higher satiety ratings (P < 0.001) and 488 kJ lower intake at lunch than the white bread breakfast, and a lupin bread lunch lowered intake at that meal by 1028 kJ. In study 2, mean 3-hour plasma ghrelin was lower after lupin bread (P = 0.009). Single-meal measures, not weight change.
Randomized crossover single-meal study of a carbohydrate-rich reference meal alone, with whey protein isolate (0.42 g/kg body weight), or with sweet lupin flour (0.94 g/kg, giving the same protein), with blood glucose and insulin measured at baseline and seven later time points. Funded by a Helmholtz Space Life Sciences Research School (SpaceLife) scholarship (Schopen et al. 2017, Front Physiol)
12 healthy men and women aged 23 to 33.
Both additions blunted the post-meal blood glucose rise versus the meal alone (P < 0.001): by 54 percent with lupin and 46 percent with whey over the first 60 minutes, with no difference between them. Insulin rose more with whey than with lupin, though neither differed from the meal alone.
Randomized, double-blind, casein-controlled parallel trial comparing 35 g/day of lupin protein with casein as the control protein for 6 weeks, with plasma lipids and amino acids measured. Funding is not stated in the abstract (Weisse et al. 2010, Eur J Nutr)
Adults with high blood cholesterol; 43 completed (23 women, 20 men).
Total cholesterol fell from baseline in both groups (by 0.50 and 0.47 mmol/L). LDL cholesterol fell within the lupin group (by 0.31 mmol/L) while HDL cholesterol fell within the casein group, so the net change in the LDL to HDL ratio was 0.24 lower with lupin (P < 0.05). Triglycerides, glucose and homocysteine did not differ between groups.