Benefits
Natural killer cell activity in an 8-week trial of germanium-enriched yeast
In 130 Korean adults, 1200 mg a day of a germanium-enriched yeast product for 8 weeks raised natural killer cell activity in a lab assay while it fell on placebo. Activity started lower in the germanium group, IgG1 only fell less than on placebo, and no infection or health outcomes were measured. The maker funded the trial.
Natural killer cell activity during short courses of Ge-132
In 18 people with cancer in Japan, Ge-132 at 1000 mg a day raised natural killer cell activity by day 3, but with daily dosing it had dropped in all of them by day 10. There was no control group and no clinical outcome, so this is a lab marker finding only.
How the body absorbs and clears Ge-132
In 24 healthy volunteers given one oral dose of Ge-132, blood germanium peaked within 2 hours and fell with a half-life of about 5 to 6 hours, and only 6 to 11% of the dose appeared in urine over 24 hours. These were single doses, so the study says nothing about long-term safety or benefit.
Organic and inorganic germanium in animal kidney studies
In rats, 24 weeks of germanium dioxide caused kidney tubule damage that kept progressing after it was stopped, while Ge-132 caused no kidney changes. A 90-day rat study of purified germanium sesquioxide found no adverse effects. An earlier 6-month rat study of Ge-132 of unstated purity reported some kidney effects, and FDA reviewers found lower toxicity of organic forms in people not conclusive.
Propagermanium as a prescription drug in Japan
Propagermanium is a germanium compound used in Japan as a prescription drug for chronic hepatitis B. Small trials have tested it in other conditions, such as a 12-month pilot in people with diabetes and kidney disease that found no drop in urine albumin. These are drug studies in patients, not evidence for germanium supplements.
Mechanism of action
Organic and inorganic forms differ chemically
In Ge-132 the germanium atom is bonded to carbon in a propanoic acid chain, and in water the polymer dissolves to a small organic acid called THGP. Germanium dioxide has no such bond. In rats the two behaved differently in the kidney, but organic products can be contaminated with germanium dioxide.
Germanium can build up in kidney tissue
In people who took germanium preparations for months, germanium accumulated in the kidney and other organs, and biopsies showed damage to the kidney tubules, with dense deposits inside the cells' mitochondria in patient biopsies and in rats. The damage often appeared without protein or blood in the urine.
Propagermanium blocks a chemokine receptor
Propagermanium is described as blocking the CCR2 receptor for the chemokine CCL2, a signal that draws immune cells into tissue. This is the basis for its testing as a drug and does not apply to Ge-132 supplements.
Clinical trials
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled single-center trial of Bio-Germanium, a germanium-enriched yeast product, 1200 mg a day for 8 weeks, funded by the maker Geranti Pharmaceutical. (Cho et al. 2020, PLoS One)
130 Korean adults (about 90% women) with white blood cell counts of 4,000 to 8,000 per microliter. 128 were analyzed (66 germanium, 62 placebo).
Natural killer cell activity rose in the germanium group and fell on placebo at all four test ratios (between-group P of 0.007 or lower), but baseline activity was significantly lower in the germanium group at three of the four ratios. IgG1 fell less than on placebo (P = 0.044) rather than rising, and IgG2 and IgM did not differ. No adverse events over 8 weeks, and kidney and liver blood tests did not change differently between groups. Lab markers only; no infection outcomes.
Uncontrolled study comparing daily and intermittent oral Ge-132 dosing, published in Japanese with an English abstract. (Tanaka et al. 1984, Gan To Kagaku Ryoho)
18 cancer patients in Japan taking Ge-132 1000 mg a day.
Natural killer cell activity was higher at day 3, but with daily dosing for 10 days it was depressed in all cases by day 10. With intermittent dosing, more than half of those who responded at day 3 kept higher activity at day 10. No control group, no clinical outcomes.
Single-dose pharmacokinetic study of oral Ge-132 at three dose levels, measuring germanium in plasma and urine. (Long et al. 1996, Zhongguo Yao Li Xue Bao)
24 healthy Chinese volunteers, 8 at each dose of 1, 2.5 or 4 g per square meter of body surface.
Peak plasma germanium came at 0.75 to 2 hours and the elimination half-life was about 5 to 6 hours at every dose. Peak levels rose with dose, while the share of germanium recovered in urine within 24 hours fell from 11% to 6%. No safety or benefit outcomes were reported.
Case series of patients who took germanium dioxide-containing compounds, with a comparison study in rats of germanium dioxide and Ge-132. (Sanai et al. 1990, Nephron)
5 patients in Japan with chronic kidney failure after taking germanium dioxide products; rats given germanium dioxide or Ge-132 orally for 10 weeks.
Kidney function declined slowly and 2 patients needed temporary dialysis. After stopping, function improved but stayed abnormal over 10 to 40 months, and there was no protein or blood in the urine. Rats on germanium dioxide developed the same tubular damage, while rats on Ge-132 did not.
Randomized, open-label, two-arm pilot trial at nine Japanese centers of the prescription drug propagermanium 30 mg a day versus usual care alone. Primary outcome: change in urine albumin-to-creatinine ratio. (Hara et al. 2020, Endocrinol Diabetes Metab)
29 adults aged 30 to 75 with type 2 diabetes and kidney disease (19 propagermanium, 10 usual care).
Propagermanium did not reduce urine albumin (change 25.0%, 95% CI -20.4% to 96.5%, P = .33). No severe adverse events or kidney events occurred. This tested a Japanese prescription drug, not a germanium supplement.
Phase I dose-escalation trial of oral propagermanium given around breast cancer surgery; primary end point was the rate of dose-limiting toxicity. (Masuda et al. 2020, Cancer Sci)
12 women with primary breast cancer in Japan.
No dose-limiting toxicity was seen and the maximum dose was set at 90 mg a day. Blood IL-6 fell with higher doses, a lab marker. A drug safety study with no control group; one author is an employee of Sanwa Kagaku Kenkyusho, which makes the drug.